Surveys find that reported life satisfaction and positive emotions tend to increase as we age, at least until we reach the point where infirmity starts detracting significantly from our quality of life. Most of the elderly are fairly optimistic about their remaining years. In fact, author Paula Span suggested in a recent New York Times article that many of them are much more optimistic than circumstances warrant. She cites findings from the “United States of Aging,” a telephone survey of Americans over age 60. Among those over 70, 23% thought their overall quality of life would improve in the next five to ten years, and 49% thought it would stay the same. Eighty-six percent of those over 70 thought they would be able to stay in their home for five to ten years without making significant modifications. The vast majority of survey respondents thought that they would be able to maintain their health over the next five to ten years and that, should an accident or unexpected medical problem occur, they would be able to pay the associated expenses. Span says, “I see much grimmer tidings elsewhere on a daily basis,” citing statistics showing paltry savings and frequent medical problems among the elderly. She tries to puzzle out the reasons for the respondents’ optimism, concluding that it reflects at least in part a developmental change associated with aging.
Right now I’m something of an exception to the rule that we become more happy and optimistic as we age. I’ve had a dip in life satisfaction over the past six months or so as I’ve retired from my primary job and moved to Michigan to be of assistance to my parents. I still work part-time; my three part-time jobs together equal about three-quarters of a full-time job. My income is reduced, and I’m driving back and forth between Michigan and North Carolina frequently. Less money and a peripatetic lifestyle trouble me some, but the biggest change is that I’ve developed more negative expectations about the future. That in turn comes from the time I spend with my parents. It’s not so much that their advanced age reminds me that they’ll soon die—and that I’ll eventually follow them. Thinking about death is disconcerting only for those who haven’t quite come to terms with their inevitable mortality. There is actually a substantial body of research indicating that thoughts of death can have beneficial effects on how we live our lives (see a report of this research here). I’m less troubled by death than by what might come before death.
My parents are in their own home and, for now anyway, are able to cover their expenses reasonably well. That doesn’t mean that they have a very pleasant life, though. My dad has dementia. He still knows who he is, recognizes family members and some friends, and can feed himself and help dress himself. However, he has to be told the most basic things, remembers very little (even the household schedule, which is repetitive to the point of monotony), and is miserable whenever away from my mom. He fears being alone, and, whenever my mom is away, he anxiously awaits her return. At night, he always needs to be reassured that someone will come to get him in the morning. My mother works hard to keep up the household and keep dad satisfied. She is plagued with various physical limitations, tires easily, and is clearly weary of the task of answering the same questions and trying to comfort someone who can’t be comforted for more than a moment. My mom has said, “I think we’ve just lived too long.” I understand why she has that view.
So I’m no longer much of an optimist when it comes to the end of life. Perhaps I’m even a pessimist, in the sense of having mostly negative expectations for what it will be like should I live to my mid-eighties or beyond. I would say that I’m a hopeful pessimist, though. Health may deteriorate, memory may fade, and friends may die, but I hope to still be sustained by qualities that can survive all these losses. The Christian tradition talks about the fruit of the Spirit—qualities that God’s Spirit develops in those who open themselves to his activity. The Apostle Paul’s letter to the Galatians lists these as love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, and self-control. Take the first three of these—if my heart were to constantly be filled with love of others, if I were to be always joyful about God’s faithfulness and mercy, and if I had an abiding sense of peace that is unperturbed by life situations, then deprivation and decrepitude would matter much less. Some days, I seem to be showing exactly the opposite of the qualities that Paul cites. I know that spiritual formation is a lifelong process, though, and I trust that God’s Spirit knows better than I do how to develop these characteristics in me. So, at this point I’m a hopeful pessimist, the in-breaking kingdom of the heavens being the only real reason I see for hope.
Leave a Reply